Original site in English

Summit on Farmer Risk: A Space for Movement-Making

Summit on Farmer Risk: Investing in a Comprehensive Farm Safety Net for Human-Scale Organic Farms

“The distance between the world as it is and the world as it could be is the space where movements make history.” Stephanie Luce, author of Practical Radicals

This spring, Marbleseed convened an eclectic group of folks to discuss farmer risk. The Summit on Farmer Risk: Investing in a Comprehensive Farm Safety Net for Human Scale Organic Farms, occurred in Chicago, IL, on April 16, after more than six months of planning.

We began with a slide that stated the problem for which we were there to solve: “Without human scale, organically managed, diversified farms, we lose our access to healthy food. This is true both locally and across many values-based supply chains. Access to healthcare and farm business insurance are critical to these farms being viable and thriving.”

Actionable solutions

The summit brought together invited leaders from sectors that do not often work closely together, including insurance, healthcare, philanthropy, and investment. Policy organizations were intentionally excluded because the planners agreed that policy solutions usually move too slowly. For people with the least financial resources and access to power, that pace is often far too slow – if change happens at all.

The day was focused on actionable solutions that were not dependent on a more friendly administration or the whims of political affiliation. Instead, we explored innovative solutions toward a farming system that works for the human-scale farms that feed us.

We heard from four speaker panels that responded to questions, such as:
• Who are the farmers and what do we know about them?
• What healthcare access solutions could meet their needs?
• How ‘risky’ are organically managed farms that are diverse and mitigate climate change?
• What finance and access to capital solutions exist to bridge the gap between conventional financing’s approach to risk and their actual risk?

It was empowering to center our creativity and solutions on small and midsize farms and farmers who have been historically underserved or disadvantaged by the current systems that support most of U.S. agriculture. So often this work happens at the margins of our current system.

After hearing from many amazing thinkers and doers, the wisdom in the room had an opportunity to come forward via smaller tabletop conversations capturing ideas that had merit for further exploration. The facilitators for the day, Shannon Sullivan with The Groundswell Alliance, and Brandon Hayes and Natalie Citro from Bold Bison, guided us through conversations on five different areas that have the potential to reduce farmer risk – including affordable healthcare, better markets for regenerative agriculture, and a climate mitigation farm safety net.

The healthcare panel generated the most interest and enthusiasm for continued work. One presenter, Dr. Natasha Diaz who runs a primary care practice in the greater Chicago area, shared a model that sidelines insurance and allows patients and doctors to make decisions together. As proven through Dr. Diaz’s practice, the model is improving continuation of care and saving money on individual procedures.

The survey says

Ahead of the Risk Summit, Marbleseed distributed a survey in which we asked farmers to share information about insurance and their farms. 32% of respondents agreed with the statement, “I would be able to grow my farm business if I was not relying on an off-farm job for health insurance.”

The survey was relaunched in the weeks following the Summit in hopes of gathering more data and asking some new questions raised by the conversations in April. See the QR code below to add your thoughts and data to this effort!

Whose risk?

One of the organizers, Zach Ducheneaux, formerly head of the federal Farm Services Agency and now principal at 5th C Capital, which works with Transformational Investing in Food Systems (TIFS), summed up the day’s approach: “Farming is risky, ag lending is not risky.”

We have an agricultural system based on large mono-cropped acreage and subsidies provided for commodities, regardless of supply or demand. Farms dependent on inputs controlled by large corporate interests are also supported by our tax dollars. The farms that truly feed us and our local economies are not served by these systems.

As a result of the gathering, everyone in attendance wanted to stay connected and continue to consider the complex issues raised. For our part, Marbleseed will be doing the following:

• Dedicate staff to develop and coordinate Farmer Risk Summit ideas and continue attendee and farmer engagement in solutions.
• Explore the feasibility of health and farm insurance risk pool approaches for the farmers in our community.
• Explore multi-faceted healthcare access options for farmers.
• Convene farmers who have indicated interest in working on these issues to further shape the solutions to make them relevant and accessible.
• Continue to utilize our mission and capacity to reduce farmer risk and climate impact through farmer education and our programs.

This event would not have been possible without speakers attending on their own dime and our financial sponsors, the Regenerative Ag Foundation and Total Administrative Service Corporation (TASC) of Madison. Our panelists represented the following organizations: AgriCap Group, Food Finance Institute, Food System 6, Organic Association of Kentucky, Organic Farmers Association, Roots Health, Stepwell Strategies, and Transformational Investing in Food Systems.